Labor Shortage Loads More Responsibility on Student Workers
October 24, 2021
Staffing issues hit local industries this year, lengthening wait times and shortening open hours in the face of an unprecedented worker shortage, The Post-Crescent said in a Sept. 3 article.
While consumers adapt to the struggling food and retail industries with patience, employers seek willing workers to fill deficits in their staff. As a result, more of the onus falls on the high school students who often fill these positions, increasing their opportunities as well as their stress levels.
“There’s just a lot of pressure to do the impossible sometimes,” Emily Wolf, NHS senior and Walmart employee said. Hired in April, Wolf worked over 30 hours a week at one point — while still in school.
After realizing the toll it took on her mental health and academic performance, she requested to reduce her hours. The switch took a while to happen, Wolf said, and in the meanwhile, the lack of proper training made her responsibilities more difficult. “They were willing to do anything to have staff in the store.”
Senior Lindsey Harris, who works at Dairy Queen on Commercial St., also noticed the effects of overscheduling on her workplace: “It’s still a fun environment, but it’s more solemn,” she said. Disgruntled customers and fatigue place a damper on workplace relationships.
Aside from workplace strain, however, the labor shortage has also opened a plethora of opportunities for students seeking employment. Harris now works as a closing assistant on some nights, gaining extra compensation and more authority.
In addition, students seeking employment can enjoy an open job market and competitive wages.
“Employers are reaching out like crazy,” Mary Schulz, NHS work-based learning (WBL) coordinator said. Schulz provides resources to connect students with the working world, whether for the WBL course, a Youth Apprenticeship program, or even volunteer opportunities. Interested students can find her in the Career Center on weekday mornings.
Overall, the upsurge of vacant positions allows students to work more hours — whether for better or worse.
School counselor Marcy Bauman said in cases where students must work extra to support their families, teachers understand and accommodate. And, she said, setting boundaries with employers and striving to balance school and work provides students with learning opportunities. As a counselor, Bauman and her colleagues in the Student Services office aim to support student workers in the process. “That’s why we’re here: to help everybody out.”
Amber Koller • Mar 29, 2022 at 1:23 PM
I have definitely seen the effects of the worker shortages throughout Neenah. I have friends who have requested to work fewer hours but have been ignored by their employees. Personally, I had to resign from my part-time job due to this issue as well. I enjoyed relating to this article and how it focuses on how students are affected.
Emma Bowman • Nov 8, 2021 at 1:01 PM
This article was insightful and relatable to the student population and to myself. I was scheduled 30 or 40 hour weeks over the summer because of understaffing and still struggle with being scheduled after requesting off for school or extracurricular activities. I feel like this article helps increase understanding and empathy for those in the student population in the workforce.
Isaiah Balassi • Nov 8, 2021 at 9:58 AM
I definitely agree with what these students are saying. I work at a Walmart as well, and I see what being understaffed is doing. A lot of responsibility is falling on part-time workers who have not been properly trained.
Rachel Kuenzi • Nov 2, 2021 at 6:12 PM
In the community overall, I definitely have seen the understaffed effect in a lot of simple places like Culvers or stores at the Fox River Mall. I didn’t consider the effect it had on students in my own grade though, and after reading this article I can definitely see why. The effects covid had on our community are far from over and I think the number of shortages and understaffed stores will have a lingering effect for a while longer. I think as a customer of these businesses we should treat the employees with more respect and appreciate their willingness to work, especially in these hard to manage circumstances
Neal Pynenberg • Nov 1, 2021 at 5:15 PM
This was a very nicely balanced article. As a parent of a senior in high school, we’ve been checking in with our teen frequently about work hours to make sure he’s not overwhelmed. While it’s hard to turn down the extra money sometimes, a balance is absolutely essential.
Grace Look • Oct 28, 2021 at 9:56 PM
There is defintely has been a staggering increase in labor shortages, and I think many in our community have seen their impact first hand as the article mentioned. I know for me, my work hours haven’t necessarily increased but we also aren’t in a position where we can afford to lose any workers. The comparison between the tole of working more and the advantages through the lens of gaining more responsibility was interesting, and not the initial approach I thought of but I believe it’s a very interesting take!
Tori Rondeau • Oct 28, 2021 at 11:15 AM
This is an issue that affects so much of the student body, and it is great to here the issue from the students point of view, rather than the employers. It is also important to share both the positives and negatives of this issue: the pressure on working students and the open job market for students looking to work. Its a pressing and timely issue, and it is so helpful to hear the stories from fellow students.
lindsey j • Oct 28, 2021 at 11:04 AM
I also relate to Lindsey Harris and Abby Wolf in the sense of “expecting to do the impossible.” I had a summer job at a local retail store, working part-time, and I would be scheduled 40 hours a week as a part-time employee. as school approached, I was still expected to work a crazy amount of hours a week cohesively with school. This was because of the low amount of staffing, however, I resigned from the job because it was affecting my schooling and overall health negatively.